Everything we know about retailer deductions, in one place.
Retailer deductions, also called chargebacks, are amounts a retailer subtracts from a supplier's invoice payment, each tied to a reason code.
Deductions and chargebacks: the basics
Many are valid. Many are not, and the difference is decided by documentation, not argument.
What is a retailer deduction?
A retailer deduction is money a retailer withholds from a supplier's invoice payment, tied to a reason code that alleges a compliance failure. It arrives as a short-pay line on a remittance advice.
What is the difference between a deduction and a chargeback?
In practice, none. The two words describe the same event: the retailer reduces what it pays and cites a reason code. Chargeback is the term in vendor compliance manuals; deduction is the term in accounts receivable.
What types of retailer chargebacks are there?
Retailer chargebacks cluster into a small number of recurring families:
- Shortage and receiving discrepancies allege the retailer got less than the invoice claims.
- Shipping and on-time-in-full (OTIF) charges allege the order arrived late, incomplete, or outside the routing guide.
- Packing and labeling non-compliance covers carton marking, ticketing, and pack configuration.
- Pricing discrepancies allege the invoiced price does not match the agreed price.
- Unauthorized return charges sit in their own category.
Look up a code
Every deduction carries a reason code, and the code is the fastest route to knowing what the retailer is alleging.
Dispute guides by retailer
Each retailer runs its own dispute process, its own channel, its own evidence expectations, and its own deadline.
Dollar General
Dollar General's three dispute teams and the window for each deduction type.
ReadKohl's
Kohl's Routing Guide (2019) rules: routing through TMS, the weekly routing calendar.
ReadBurlington
Filing a Burlington deduction dispute: channel, evidence requirements, and window.
ReadBealls
Bealls deduction types, how disputes are submitted.
ReadKroger
Kroger deduction reason codes and dispute route.
ReadTJX
TJX's VSS user guide (April 2006): chargebacks are mailed with the check.
ReadRoss Stores
Ross's domestic routing guide (September 2024): when to request routing, keeping Ross and dd's freight apart.
ReadPlaybooks and guides
Start here if you are working out what a deduction is, which of them are worth challenging, and what the words mean.
What is retailer deduction recovery?
ReadDeduction KPIs: Definitions and Formulas
ReadAllowance and Markdown Deductions
ReadOTIF Fines: How They Work by Retailer
ReadFreight and Routing Deductions Explained
ReadReturns and RTV Deductions Explained
ReadEDI Compliance Chargebacks Explained
ReadFiling a Freight Claim Against the Carrier
Who files a freight claim, what it must contain, and how shipper load and count affects a shortage claim.
ReadPricing and Cost-Difference Deductions
ReadValid vs Invalid Retailer Deductions
ReadNew Vendor Onboarding With a Retailer
ReadThe Legal Basis for Retailer Deductions
ReadThe Bankruptcy Code and Open Invoices
ReadWho Bears the Loss in Transit
ReadThe Sales Law Text on Limitation Periods
ReadThe Commercial Code Text on Full Satisfaction
ReadDeep dives
Longer pieces on the chargeback families: shortages, OTIF and shipping compliance, packing and labeling, and freight and relay.
How other teams handle it
Deduction management gets handled in different ways, from spreadsheets and a deduction analyst to dedicated software to an AI agent.
Frequently asked
Does ROIAI One dispute deductions automatically?
Roy gathers the underlying documents, matches them against the retailer's claim, and assembles a dispute packet with the reasoning laid out, including a recommendation not to dispute, which is sometimes the right call.
Review is selective and exception-based. ROIAI One's own analysts review the exceptions that need judgment, not the customer's team.
Auto-submission is off by default for every reason code, and enabling it for a given reason code is a deliberate change that only ROIAI One's analysts can make, and they can turn it off again.
You can also switch off the auto-submit settings for any of your retailers yourself, which stops automatic filing for that retailer.
Working out what your deductions actually cost you?
Start with a recovery assessment, or run the numbers yourself in the calculator.