EDI compliance chargebacks

EDI Compliance Chargebacks Explained

Which EDI document failures become a chargeback

An EDI chargeback happens when one of four electronic documents is missing, late, or doesn't match what actually shipped, and the retailer charges the vendor for it.

Each retailer publishes its own EDI rules and fees, so the same miss gets charged differently depending on who's charging it.

Document, what it is, who sends it to whom, and source.
DocumentWhat it isWho sends it to whomSource
850 (purchase order)The retailer's order.Retailer sends to vendor.Burlington manual, p.4.
856 (ASN)Advance notice of a shipment's contents.Vendor sends to retailer.Burlington manual, p.4.
810 (invoice)The vendor's bill for goods shipped.Vendor sends to retailer.Burlington manual, p.4.
997 (functional acknowledgment)Confirms a transmission was received and correctly formed.Whichever party received the document sends this back to whoever sent it.Burlington manual, p.4-5.

The purchase order (850) and its acknowledgment

The retailer sends the 850 purchase order to the vendor. Some retailers, Bealls for example, also require the vendor to send back a PO acknowledgment and charge the vendor when it's missing, late, or unusable.

Who, and does what.
WhoDoes what
RetailerSends the 850 purchase order to the vendor.
VendorWhere required, sends back an 855 PO acknowledgment.
BeallsCharges the vendor for a "No/late/unusable 855 (PO Acknowledgement)" (code 905-A).

The ASN (856): missing, late, or mismatched

The vendor sends the 856 ASN to the retailer to describe a shipment before it arrives, and each retailer sets its own deadline and accuracy rules for it.

Miss, example retailer rule, charge, and source.
MissExample retailer ruleChargeSource
Late transmissionBurlington: within 24 hours of carrier pickup; Kroger: within 1 hour of the truck leaving.Set by each retailer's program.Burlington p.4; Kroger VNC 2025.
Missing or unusable ASNBealls code 151.Bealls charges the vendor; Fred Meyer only: a fee when the ASN and its GS1-128 labels do not confirm.Bealls Chargeback Policy; Kroger VNC 2025.
ASN-to-carton mismatchBurlington: ASN carton identifiers must match the shipping label.Bealls code 802: "856 ASN invalid and/or incorrect data."Burlington p.5; Bealls Chargeback Policy.
Missing required ASN dataKohl's: the ASN must include the BOL number and the SCAC.Set by each retailer's program.Kohl's Routing Guide p.11.

The invoice (810), and what a 997 proves

The vendor sends the 810 invoice to the retailer. Bealls, for example, charges the vendor for an "810 Invoice invalid and/or incorrect data" (code 801) and an "810 Invoice not sent via EDI" (code 803).

A 997 backs up your transmission log, but it never proves the contents were right.

Kroger requires the vendor to acknowledge the transactions it receives within the standard's window "or within twenty-four (24) hours, whichever is the shorter period."

Vendors shipping to Kroger distribution centers get "ninety (90) days" to receive POs and return invoices via EDI before a fee applies.

WHAT THE 997 PROVES, AND WHAT IT DOES NOTWHAT THE 997 PROVESWHAT THE 997 DOES NOT PROVEA transmission was receivedand correctly formedThe contents were accurate

See also:

Roy prepares the dispute for review. Want to know where your own EDI compliance chargebacks stand? Get a deduction assessment.

Questions

Frequently asked questions

What is an EDI compliance chargeback?

A charge a retailer takes from the vendor when an 850 purchase order, 856 ASN, 810 invoice, or 997 acknowledgment is missing, late, or doesn't match the shipment.

Does a 997 functional acknowledgment prove an ASN or invoice was correct?

No. A 997 only confirms a transmission was received and correctly formed. It never confirms the contents were accurate.

Not sure where your EDI compliance chargebacks stand?

Get a quick assessment of your open EDI compliance chargebacks.

Chat with Roy