Apparel and fashion

Apparel retailer chargebacks

Deductions follow each retailer's own rulebook, whatever channel you sell into. The retailers we document set their own reason codes, filing channels and dispute clocks. Roy reads the deduction and gathers your documents, and ROIAI One's analysts review and release the dispute.

The shape of the category

Where the rules live

  • Each retailer's own vendor manual, routing guide or chargeback policy

Counting level

  • Burlington counts cartons on a pallet
  • Bealls compares invoiced units with units received

Reason codes

  • Each retailer defines its own deduction codes
  • Bealls sorts its error codes into five groups
  • Burlington marks each item type with a prefix, such as DMQ for a shortage

The clock

  • Starts from a different event at each retailer
What the documents say

One shipment, four rulebooks

One shipment
  • Burlington

    Counts cartons on arrival.

  • Bealls

    Lists each charge as an expense offset with an error code.

  • Macy's

    Calls its compliance charges expense offsets.

  • Kohl's

    Collect shipments must ship with the carrier its routing system assigned.

One shipment, four retailer documents

A retailer judges a shipment against its own document. These four documents name different things.

RetailerWhat its own document names
BurlingtonCounts cartons on arrival. Fewer cartons on a pallet than the bill of lading lists is a concealed shortage, and the vendor is liable.
BeallsLists each charge as an expense offset with an error code, including wrong carton marking, a missing or incorrect label, and goods shipped outside the purchase order shipping window.
Macy'sCalls its compliance charges expense offsets and lists them in Appendix H of its Vendor Standards.
Kohl'sCollect shipments must ship with the carrier its routing system assigned. Use another carrier and the vendor is liable for goods lost or damaged in transit.

What drives deductions here

DriverWhat happens
Counting at receiptThe retailer's count and your records disagree. The gap is booked as a shortage.
Carrier and routingA carrier other than the assigned one is used. Bealls has a code for shipping on an unassigned carrier.
Carton marking and labelsBealls charges wrong carton marking and a missing or incorrect label.
Ship windowGoods shipped outside the purchase order shipping window, or against a cancelled order, draw a Bealls charge.

Same deduction, different clock

STARTS FROMLENGTHDollar GeneralShort-paid invoicewaived by the vendor if the dispute isunresolved, or sent, after 90 daysPayment90 daysPost auditThe payment it appeared onWithin 90 daysVendor performancenot looked into or repaid once olderNot statedSix monthsBurlingtonShortage disputesCheck remittanceWithin 6 monthsMacy'sMacy'sThe deduction date60 daysReturn claimsshortages, damages, non-deliveryThe financial deductionWithin 90 daysBeallsExpense offsetcorrespondence must startThe expense offset check dateWithin 6 monthsKrogerAdvice messageson check stubs (legacy path)Issuance180 daysLavante billing inquiriesmust be resolvedThe original invoice dateWithin 180 daysWindows start from different events, so compare the start as well as the length.

Scroll sideways

Dispute windows start from different events.

RetailerThe clock starts fromLength
BurlingtonCheck remittanceSix months, for shortage disputes
BeallsThe expense offset check dateSix months
Macy'sThe deduction dateSixty days. Macy's Backstage has its own standards.
Dollar GeneralPayment, for short-paid and post audit claimsNinety days. Vendor performance deductions are not looked into once older than six months.
Kohl's, payment disputesThe invoice payment dateSix months
Kohl's, shortage claimsKohl's receipt of goodsSix months

The questions a dispute in this category turns on

Bill ofladingInvoiceEDI 856ASNPOProof ofdeliveryDollar GeneralKohl'sBurlingtonMacy'sBeallsKrogerTJXRoss StoresNamed in the guideBlank: not named in our guide, never "not required".Other documents each guide names are in the table. TJX: our guide names the chargeback, mailed with the physical check.
A filled mark means the guide names the document
  • The counting level. Retailers do not count one shared unit. Our glossary notes that a concealed shortage has no single industry definition.
  • Proof of delivery. Each retailer decides what counts. Burlington accepts only a bill of lading signed or stamped by its receivers. Dollar General wants a bill of lading with the distribution center stamp and case counts for a prepaid shortage. See proof of delivery.
  • Who counted and sealed. At Burlington, a trailer the shipper counted, loaded and sealed that arrives with the seal intact is not Burlington's or the carrier's liability for a carton shortage on the bill of lading.
Questions

Questions on apparel deductions

Why does a retailer book a shortage when the shipment arrived?

Because each retailer sets how it counts. Burlington counts cartons at receipt and defines a concealed shortage as fewer cartons on a pallet than the bill of lading lists. Bealls compares invoiced units with units received. Our glossary notes that neither is a single industry definition.

How long do I have to dispute an apparel deduction?

It depends on the retailer and on the event the clock starts from. Burlington: six months from check remittance, for shortage disputes. Bealls: six months from the expense offset check date. Macy's: sixty days from the deduction date. Dollar General sets different periods by deduction type. Kohl's: six months from the invoice payment date for payment disputes, and six months from Kohl's receipt of goods for shortage claims.

Where do I file an apparel deduction dispute?

It depends on the retailer. Burlington takes shortage disputes by email to Vendor Relations. Macy's uses its macysnet AP Forms. Dollar General sends each kind of deduction to its own team: Accounts Payable, VNC Disputes or Post Audit.

Do two retailers use the same reason code for the same problem?

No. Each retailer defines its own codes and its own remittance layout, so the retailer's own notice is the authority. Our deduction code library lists codes by retailer.

See it against your own deductions

Chat with Roy