Toys, games and novelty gift

Toy and game retailer chargebacks

Shortage claims turn on the level a retailer counts at: cartons, cases or invoiced units. This page covers goods that ship as assortments, prepacks and multi piece sets, including party games, card games and novelty gift. Roy reads the deduction and gathers your documents, and ROIAI One's analysts review and release the dispute.

The shape of the category

Scope

  • Goods that ship as assortments, prepacks and multi piece sets, including party games, card games and novelty gift

Where the rules live

  • Each retailer's own vendor manual, routing guide or chargeback policy

Counting level

  • Set by each retailer's own document

The clock

  • Runs from the retailer's own start event, not from the end of your season
What the documents say

The counting level

One shipment
  • Carton

    Burlington: cartons are counted at receipt.

  • Case

    Dollar General: case counts on a prepaid shortage.

  • Unit

    Bealls: invoiced units against units received.

One shipment, counted three ways

Each retailer writes the level it counts at into its own document, and they differ.

RetailerHow its own document counts
BurlingtonCartons are counted at receipt. A concealed shortage is fewer cartons on a pallet than the bill of lading lists.
BeallsIts concealed shortage code compares invoiced units with units received.
Dollar GeneralA prepaid shortage rests on a bill of lading with the distribution center stamp and case counts.

Our glossary notes that neither the carton reading nor the unit reading is a single industry definition of a concealed shortage.

What drives deductions here

DriverWhat happens
Counting at receiptCounts differ by retailer. The gap is booked as a shortage.
Delivery windowBealls charges goods shipped outside the purchase order shipping window, or against a cancelled order. Kroger's published ORAD fee turns on timing.
Allowances and returnsAn allowance is set by a signed rate in the vendor agreement, purchase order or promotion terms. A return can arrive as a return to vendor deduction.

The window, not the season

STARTS FROMLENGTHDollar GeneralShort-paid invoicewaived by the vendor if the dispute isunresolved, or sent, after 90 daysPayment90 daysPost auditThe payment it appeared onWithin 90 daysVendor performancenot looked into or repaid once olderNot statedSix monthsBurlingtonShortage disputesCheck remittanceWithin 6 monthsMacy'sMacy'sThe deduction date60 daysReturn claimsshortages, damages, non-deliveryThe financial deductionWithin 90 daysBeallsExpense offsetcorrespondence must startThe expense offset check dateWithin 6 monthsKrogerAdvice messageson check stubs (legacy path)Issuance180 daysLavante billing inquiriesmust be resolvedThe original invoice dateWithin 180 daysWindows start from different events, so compare the start as well as the length.

Scroll sideways

Retailer windows count from events such as the deduction date, the payment or the check remittance. Burlington tells vendors not to accumulate shortage disputes on a monthly, quarterly, seasonal or annual basis.

RetailerThe clock starts fromLength
BurlingtonCheck remittanceSix months, for shortage disputes
BeallsThe expense offset check dateSix months
Macy'sThe deduction dateSixty days. Macy's Backstage has its own standards.
Dollar GeneralPayment, for short-paid and post audit claimsNinety days. Vendor performance deductions are not looked into once older than six months.

The questions a dispute in this category turns on

Bill ofladingInvoiceEDI 856ASNPOProof ofdeliveryDollar GeneralKohl'sBurlingtonMacy'sBeallsKrogerTJXRoss StoresNamed in the guideBlank: not named in our guide, never "not required".Other documents each guide names are in the table. TJX: our guide names the chargeback, mailed with the physical check.
  • The counting level. Read the retailer's own definition of a shortage before you reply, because definitions differ.
  • The arrival record. At Kroger, a late delivery deduction turns on arrival against ORAD, the exact date the purchase order must reach the distribution center.
  • The proof of delivery. Each retailer decides what counts. Burlington accepts only a bill of lading signed or stamped by its receivers. Dollar General does not count the bill of lading given when a trailer is dropped. See proof of delivery.
Questions

Questions on toy and game deductions

Why can a full shipment draw a shortage?

Because each retailer sets the level it counts at. Burlington counts cartons at receipt and defines a concealed shortage as fewer cartons on a pallet than the bill of lading lists. Bealls compares invoiced units with units received. Dollar General rests a prepaid shortage on case counts. Our glossary notes that neither carton nor unit counting is a single industry definition.

When does the dispute clock start?

It depends on the retailer. Burlington counts from check remittance, Bealls from the expense offset check date, Macy's from the deduction date, and Dollar General from the payment for short-paid and post audit claims. None of these starts at the end of your season.

Does a signed delivery document end a shortage dispute?

It depends on what the retailer accepts. Burlington accepts only a BOL signed or stamped by its receivers. Dollar General says the bill of lading given when a trailer is dropped shows shipment, not cases received, so it does not count there.

Should I wait until the season ends to dispute?

Not if the retailer's window is running. Burlington tells vendors: "Do not accumulate shortage disputes on a monthly, quarterly, seasonal, or annual basis." Dollar General does not look into or repay a vendor performance deduction once it is older than six months.

See it against your own deductions

Chat with Roy