Guides

Deduction guides, indexed by the question they answer

What is here

These are the long-form guides behind our deduction work, indexed by the question each one answers rather than by title. Find your question in the table below and go straight to the guide that settles it.

Every question

What the guides answer, and where

Every question answered across the ROIAI One deduction guides, and which guide answers each one.
QuestionAnswered in
What is retailer deduction recovery?Definition
Is deduction recovery the same as tax recovery?Definition
Is ROIAI One a recruitment or HR software company?Definition
Is a recovery agency or software better for retailer deductions?Decision guide
Can you dispute retailer deductions without an ERP?Decision guide
Can we use an agency and software at the same time?Decision guide
Is Roy replacing my deduction analyst?Division of labour
What is the difference between a digital employee and deduction software?Division of labour
Who decides which reason codes are submitted without a review step?Division of labour
What happens to a retailer deduction when you have factored the receivable?Factoring and deductions
Can you still dispute a retailer deduction after selling the receivable?Factoring and deductions
How does a recovery on a factored invoice reach the vendor?Factoring and deductions
How can I tell a retailer chargeback from a credit card chargeback?Chargeback basics
What is a chargeback in retail?Chargeback basics
What is a credit card chargeback?Chargeback basics
Who pays a retail chargeback?Chargeback basics
Is a chargeback the same thing as a deduction?Chargeback basics
What is the difference between the deduction rate and the dispute rate?Deduction metrics
What is the difference between the recovery rate and the write-off rate?Deduction metrics
What is the difference between Days Deductions Outstanding and time to resolution?Deduction metrics
What is an allowance, co-op, or markdown deduction?Allowance disputes
How do allowance deductions differ from compliance or shortage deductions?Allowance disputes
Where can a retailer dispute your invoice?Invoice disputes
What does a clean invoice have to match?Invoice disputes
When does it become a deduction dispute?Invoice disputes
Can I reuse an invoice number to bill extra money?Invoice disputes
What does OTIF actually measure?OTIF and shipping compliance
How CVS turns OTIF into a chargebackOTIF and shipping compliance
How Kroger measures on-time delivery (ORAD)OTIF and shipping compliance
Where Walmart and other retailers standOTIF and shipping compliance
What counts as a freight or routing-guide violation?Freight and routing compliance
How a routing violation becomes a chargebackFreight and routing compliance
Detention, demurrage, and missed-appointment chargesFreight and routing compliance
What is a return-to-vendor (RTV) deduction?Returns and RTV deductions
What is an unauthorized return, and how is it different from an RTV?Returns and RTV deductions
Which EDI documents does a supplier exchange with a retailer?EDI basics
Who are the trading partners, and what does a provider do?EDI basics
What do the numbers on EDI documents mean?EDI basics
Why does a missing or late document become a chargeback?EDI basics
What is an EDI compliance chargeback?EDI compliance chargebacks
Does a functional acknowledgment prove an ASN or invoice was correct?EDI compliance chargebacks
Who files a freight claim, and who is it filed with?Carrier freight claims
What must a freight claim contain?Carrier freight claims
What is the minimum filing deadline for a freight claim against a carrier?Carrier freight claims
What SLC on the bill of lading recordsCarrier freight claims
What is a pricing or cost-difference deduction?Pricing and cost-difference deductions
How is a price-difference deduction different from an allowance or markdown deduction?Pricing and cost-difference deductions
Which retailers publish a response time for deduction disputes?After a denial
Can you escalate a denied deduction dispute?After a denial
Which fields does each deduction need?Deduction reporting
How often should you review a deduction report?Deduction reporting
Is a deduction dashboard different from a deduction report?Deduction reporting
How do the revenue standards treat a retailer deduction?Deduction accounting
How do you estimate deductions that have not arrived yet?Deduction accounting
How much of the estimate can you book, and when does it change?Deduction accounting
What records does a reserve need behind it?Deduction accounting
Does a reason code make a deduction valid?Retailer deductions
Is a deduction invalid if the retailer takes it late?Retailer deductions
Where does Macy's list the expense offsets it may take?Retailer deductions
Does a supplier have to sign a vendor agreement before shipping?Retailer onboarding
Can a new supplier negotiate the terms?Retailer onboarding
What does a new vendor checklist cover?Retailer onboarding
Can a buyer deduct from a price still due?Legal basis
What does the text name for a deduction?Legal basis
Who has the burden after acceptance?Legal basis
What does an unexplained deduction leave open?Legal basis
What does the automatic stay cover?Bankruptcy Code
What does the Code say under the heading Preferences?Bankruptcy Code
What does the Code list for goods received within a stated period before a case begins?Bankruptcy Code
When does risk of loss pass to the buyer?Risk of loss
When does risk pass if a particular destination is required?Risk of loss
What can change the default?Risk of loss
What does the sales law text say about a limitation period?Limitation periods
What does the sales law text say about when a cause of action accrues?Limitation periods
What does the sales law text say about the parties' agreement?Limitation periods
What does the Commercial Code text say about an instrument tendered as full satisfaction?Full satisfaction
What does the Commercial Code text say about a conspicuous statement?Full satisfaction
What does the Commercial Code text say about a reservation of rights?Full satisfaction
The guides

The headline question each one settles

Definition

What is retailer deduction recovery?

It is the process of disputing and reclaiming money a retailer withheld from a supplier's invoice. The retailer short-pays and cites a reason code alleging a compliance failure. Some of those claims are valid and some are not.

Written for: Someone at a wholesaler, manufacturer, or distributor who ships physical goods to retailers and watches money disappear off their remittances.

Read: What Is Retailer Deduction Recovery?

Decision guide

Is a recovery agency or software better for retailer deductions?

Neither is better in general. An agency is better with no system worth connecting, a one-off backlog, or nobody to own the process. Software is better when deductions keep arriving and your systems hold the evidence. The real difference is not price but where the evidence comes from, and how much of your own operation you are willing to own.

Written for: A finance leader choosing an approach, including one for whom an agency is the better answer. The guide argues the agency case honestly and names the situations where ROIAI One is the wrong choice.

Read: Software, Agency, In-House, or Absorb

Division of labour

Is Roy replacing my deduction analyst?

No. Roy does the working half of a retailer deduction case and your deduction analyst keeps the judgment half. Review is selective and exception-based, and it is carried by ROIAI One's own analysts rather than your team.

Written for: A team evaluating the working arrangement rather than the decision: who does which step of a case, and what stays with the analyst you already employ.

Read: A Digital Employee and Your Analyst

Factoring and deductions

What happens to a retailer deduction when you have factored the receivable?

When you factor a receivable and the retailer short-pays that invoice, the invoice does not settle as expected, and the shortfall has to land somewhere. Where your agreement gives the factor recourse for that shortfall, it lands back on the vendor, by charging the invoice back, by holding it against the reserve, or by netting it against future advances. The vendor holds the evidence and owns the operational root cause either way, while the cash now moves through the factor.

Written for: A vendor who has sold the receivable and needs to know who absorbs the shortfall, who can still dispute it, and which provisions of their own factoring agreement decide both.

Read: Retailer Deductions When You Factor

Chargeback basics

How can I tell a retailer chargeback from a credit card chargeback?

A retailer chargeback is a deduction from what a retailer owes its supplier; a card chargeback reverses a consumer payment. How they differ, side by side.

Written for: A supplier holding a retailer deduction, not a credit card dispute.

Read: Retailer vs Credit Card Chargebacks

Deduction metrics

What is the difference between the deduction rate and the dispute rate?

The deduction rate expresses total deductions taken as a percentage of sales. It says nothing about what happens afterward. The dispute rate expresses how much of the deductions received get formally challenged. The two measure different things.

Written for: Finance and credit teams measuring a deduction workload.

Read: Deduction KPIs: Definitions and Formulas

Allowance disputes

What is an allowance, co-op, or markdown deduction?

A trade promotion, allowance, co-op, or markdown deduction is money a retailer withholds under a deal the vendor already agreed to. It's not a penalty for a shipping or paperwork error. It funds a promotion, an ad program, a margin shortfall, or a new-store or new-item rebate.

Written for: The deduction analyst or AR lead holding a trade promotion, co-op, or markdown allowance deduction on a remittance.

Read: Allowance and Markdown Deductions

Invoice disputes

Where can a retailer dispute your invoice?

At three points: when the invoice arrives, while it is matched, and when it is paid. The retailer may reject it, hold it over a mismatch, or pay less than billed, and each stage shows up in a different place.

Written for: A supplier or accounts receivable lead who sells to retailers and needs to tell a rejected or held invoice from a short payment, and to know where each shows up.

Read: Invoice Disputes in Accounts Receivable

OTIF and shipping compliance

What does OTIF actually measure?

OTIF stands for on-time and in-full: whether a purchase order arrived when the retailer required it, and whether it arrived with the full quantity ordered. Each retailer defines both halves on its own window, so the same term produces different fees and deadlines depending on who's charging it.

Written for: The deduction analyst or AR lead holding an OTIF fine who needs to know what CVS and Kroger actually measure.

Read: OTIF Fines: How They Work by Retailer

Freight and routing compliance

What counts as a freight or routing-guide violation?

A miss against a retailer's own rulebook for getting freight to it, such as shipping without a placed routing request, using an unassigned carrier or facility, or shipping on the wrong freight terms, rather than a miss on quantity.

Written for: The deduction analyst or AR lead holding a freight, routing, detention, or demurrage charge who needs to know what the charge is.

Read: Freight and Routing Deductions Explained

Returns and RTV deductions

What is a return-to-vendor (RTV) deduction?

A deduction a retailer takes when it physically ships merchandise back to you and bills the cost, freight, or a handling fee against your account, rather than paying for it. It's distinct from a shortage (goods never arrived) or a compliance fine (a process miss).

Written for: The deduction analyst or AR lead holding a return-to-vendor deduction, a defective merchandise charge, or an unauthorized return who needs to know what the charge is.

Read: Returns and RTV Deductions Explained

EDI basics

Which EDI documents does a supplier exchange with a retailer?

A purchase order, a purchase order acknowledgment, a ship notice, an invoice and a remittance advice, each confirmed by a functional acknowledgment. The industry standard defines each document, and each retailer's own guide sets which ones it requires.

Written for: A supplier or accounts receivable lead who sells to retailers and needs to know which electronic documents change hands, who carries them, and why a late one can be charged.

Read: EDI Basics for Wholesale Suppliers

EDI compliance chargebacks

What is an EDI compliance chargeback?

A charge a retailer takes from the vendor when a purchase order, an ASN, an invoice, or a functional acknowledgment transmitted electronically is missing, late, or doesn't match the shipment.

Written for: The deduction analyst or AR lead holding an EDI compliance chargeback who needs to know what the charge is.

Read: EDI Compliance Chargebacks Explained

Carrier freight claims

Who files a freight claim, and who is it filed with?

The claimant is the person entitled to recover under the receipt or bill of lading. You file the claim with a carrier the Carmack Amendment makes liable.

Written for: The deduction analyst or AR lead who needs to file a freight claim with the carrier rather than dispute a retailer deduction, and needs to know who may file, what the claim must contain, and the filing and response deadlines that apply.

Read: Filing a Freight Claim Against the Carrier

Pricing and cost-difference deductions

What is a pricing or cost-difference deduction?

A deduction taken when the cost a retailer pays doesn't match what you invoiced. The retailer pays and deducts; you're the one who sent the invoice.

Written for: The deduction analyst or AR lead who needs to know what a pricing or cost-difference deduction is.

Read: Pricing and Cost-Difference Deductions

After a denial

Which retailers publish a response time for deduction disputes?

Two of the eight retailers we cover. Dollar General's Accounts Payable aims to answer short-paid invoice inquiries within 60 days, and Burlington answers shortage disputes within 60 business days. These are response times, not filing windows.

Written for: Someone at a wholesaler or supplier who filed a retailer dispute and wants the response time the retailer publishes.

Read: What does each retailer publish after you file?

Deduction reporting

Which fields does each deduction need?

Retailer, the identifiers the retailer's system uses, deduction code, amount, deduction date, reason category, status, dispute date, resolution date, and reversed and written-off amounts. Most KPI formulas read from these fields. Sales and cost figures come from other records.

Written for: A finance, credit or AR lead at a wholesaler or brand who must produce a deduction report or dashboard and has the KPI definitions but not the data layout.

Read: How to Build a Deduction Report

Deduction accounting

How do the revenue standards treat a retailer deduction?

The revenue standards generally treat amounts paid or credited to a customer as a reduction of revenue. A supplier estimates the deductions it expects. The standards limit how much uncertain revenue is included, and the estimate changes with the facts. This guide calls that estimate a reserve or an accrual.

Written for: A controller, finance lead or AR manager at a supplier who needs the vocabulary of the revenue standards before talking to accountants.

Read: Accounting for Retailer Deductions

Retailer deductions

Does a reason code make a deduction valid?

No. A deduction is valid when the retailer's own published terms establish the charge. It is invalid when those terms do not support it.

Written for: Someone at a wholesaler or supplier who needs to tell whether a retailer deduction is valid or unsupported by the retailer's own terms.

Read: Valid vs Invalid Retailer Deductions

Retailer onboarding

Does a supplier have to sign a vendor agreement before shipping?

Not always. Kroger's agreement (January 2017) treats shipping on a purchase order as unconditional acceptance if no signed page returns in time.

Written for: Someone at a supplier who needs to know which documents a retailer's onboarding has them accept.

Read: New Vendor Onboarding With a Retailer

Legal basis

Can a buyer deduct from a price still due?

Under UCC 2-717, a buyer, on notifying the seller of its intention to do so, may deduct damages resulting from a breach of the contract from the price still due under the same contract.

Written for: Someone at a wholesaler, manufacturer, or distributor who wants to read what the uniform sales law text says about a buyer deducting damages from a price still due.

Read: The Legal Basis for Retailer Deductions

Bankruptcy Code

What does the automatic stay cover?

The automatic stay provision of the Bankruptcy Code says that, except as provided in its subsection (b), a petition operates as a stay, applicable to all entities, of the items it lists, including any act to collect, assess, or recover a claim against the debtor that arose before the commencement of the case.

Written for: Someone at a wholesaler, manufacturer, or distributor who wants to read four sections of the Bankruptcy Code in the text's own words.

Read: The Bankruptcy Code and Open Invoices

Risk of loss

When does risk of loss pass to the buyer?

Where the contract requires or authorizes shipment by carrier, the text says risk passes on duly delivering the goods to the carrier or, if a particular destination is required, on duly tendering them there. It makes this subject to contrary agreement of the parties.

Written for: Someone at a wholesaler or manufacturer who wants to know what the sales law text says about when risk of loss passes on goods shipped by carrier.

Read: Who Bears the Loss in Transit

Limitation periods

What does the sales law text say about a limitation period?

The Uniform Commercial Code section on contracts for sale states a period and the event from which it is counted, and has a subsection on when a cause of action accrues. This guide points to the text and does not restate the period.

Written for: Someone at a wholesaler or manufacturer who wants to read what the sales law text says about the period for an action on a contract for sale.

Read: The Sales Law Text on Limitation Periods

Full satisfaction

What does the Commercial Code text say about an instrument tendered as full satisfaction?

The Uniform Commercial Code has a section on an instrument tendered to a claimant as full satisfaction of a claim, and a separate section on performance under an explicit reservation of rights. This guide quotes the text and does not say whether either applies to any item.

Written for: Someone at a wholesaler or manufacturer who wants to read the text of two Uniform Commercial Code sections on full satisfaction and a reservation of rights.

Read: The Commercial Code Text on Full Satisfaction

If your question is not here

The guides argue. The libraries look things up.

A guide answers a question you have to think about. If instead you need a specific fact, the reference libraries are the faster route: the deduction code library for what an individual reason code means, and the retailer intelligence library for the submission channel and reason-code taxonomy at a specific retailer.

If the question is about us rather than about deductions, the platform pages describe what Roy is and how it connects to your systems, the solutions pages route by the problem you are seeing, and the deduction knowledge hub collects all of it in one place.

Or skip the reading and use your own numbers

Every one of these guides ends in the same place: what your own deduction history actually says. You can start there instead.

Chat with Roy