Allowance disputes

Allowance and Markdown Deductions

What is an allowance, co-op, or markdown deduction?

A trade promotion, allowance, co-op, or markdown deduction is money a retailer withholds under a deal the vendor already agreed to. It's not a penalty for a shipping or paperwork error.

It funds a promotion, an ad program, a margin shortfall, or a new-store or new-item rebate.

Allowance types, how each is agreed, and where each shows up on a remittance.
Allowance typeHow it's agreedWhere it shows up
Markdown / margin supportNegotiated rate in the vendor agreement or PO terms.Burlington code "MD" (mark down).
New-store / new-item allowanceStandard rebate program rate set by the retailer.Deduction at the program's current standard rate.
Price difference / discount / substitutionPO terms or a price-change notice.Burlington code "DMC".

How do allowance deductions differ from compliance or shortage deductions?

An allowance or markdown deduction is built from a deal both sides signed. A compliance or shortage deduction is built from an event, such as a carton-count mismatch or a labeling error.

The test is simple.

Does a document defining the rate exist, or only a document describing what went wrong?

Allowance and markdown deductions versus compliance and shortage deductions: what creates each.
Deduction familyWhat creates it
Allowance / markdown / co-opA signed rate in the vendor agreement, PO, or promotion terms.
Compliance / shortageA shipping, labeling, or receiving event.

What does federal law say about promotional allowances?

Section 2(d) of the Robinson-Patman Act makes it unlawful for a seller engaged in commerce to pay a customer for promotional services unless the payment is available on proportionally equal terms to the seller's other customers competing in the distribution of its products.

A seller pays orfurnishes apromotional serviceOn proportionallyequal termsTo customerscompeting in thedistribution ofits products15 U.S.C. 13(d) and (e); 16 CFR 240.2
Elements the cited text names, side by side. They are not steps or a test. Sections 2(d) and 2(e) speak to the seller that pays or furnishes the service.

Section 2(e) covers the other side: a seller that furnishes promotional services or facilities to its customers, which must be on terms that are proportionally equal. The FTC's Guides for Advertising Allowances give examples, such as cooperative advertising, catalogues and displays. They say the list is not exhaustive.

The guides add that the services must be used primarily to promote the customer's resale of the seller's product. They say no single method is prescribed. The guides say proportionally equal terms can most easily be set by basing payments or services on dollar volume or quantity purchased over a specified period.

The guides say the seller should take reasonable precautions to see that the services it pays for are furnished, and that it is not overpaying for them.

Sections 2(d) and 2(e) speak to the seller that pays or furnishes the service. The guides describe a plan for that seller. These sections cover promotional services and facilities tied to a customer's resale of the seller's products. The cited text does not mention deductions. This section does not say whether any particular deduction is valid.

This explains the cited text. This is not legal advice. This does not say whether any particular deduction or practice complies with the law.

Sources: 15 U.S.C. 13(d) and (e); 16 CFR Part 240, sections 240.1, 240.2, 240.7, 240.9 and 240.12.

Questions

Frequently asked questions

Is a markdown allowance the same as a chargeback?

No. An allowance is built from an agreement both sides signed. A chargeback or compliance deduction is built from an event, such as a shipping or labeling error.

Do the FTC advertising allowance guides have the force of law?

No. The guides call themselves guidelines for compliance with the law and say they do not have the force of law. They assist businesses seeking to comply with sections 2(d) and (e) of the Robinson-Patman Act and are based on the statute's language, the legislative history, administrative and court decisions, and the purposes of the Act. Source: 16 CFR 240.1.

Check your own deductions

Chat with Roy