Backward look

Historic Deduction Audit

What a historic audit is

A historic deduction audit is a backward-looking analysis of retailer deductions taken against a supplier's invoice that have already been settled and closed.

Which one

Historic Audit or Assessment?

Most readers should start with a Chargeback Recovery Assessment, not a historic audit. The historic audit is the right first step only when your question is about the past.

Historic audit

What it looks at

Deductions already taken and already closed, including those never disputed, disputes that were abandoned, duplicates, deductions taken more than once, and deductions repaid but never credited back.

The period

Backward, over the period you choose, bounded by what your export covers.

The question it answers

What did we absorb without ever examining it, and what caused it.

You are reading its page.

Recognise yourself

Who a Historic Audit Suits

A historic audit suits a reader whose open question is about deductions that are already closed. These situations recur:

  • A change of ownership or finance leadership. Someone has inherited a deduction book nobody examined and needs to know what is in it before they own the consequences of it.

  • A company that has never disputed. Before building a forward process, the reader wants to know the size and shape of what was absorbed, so the decision to build is made on evidence rather than instinct.

  • A company preparing a retailer trading-terms renegotiation. A negotiation about compliance terms and deduction practice goes better with the historic pattern documented than with it asserted.

If none of these describe you, your question is probably about the money still on the table rather than the money already gone. Start with a Chargeback Recovery Assessment instead.

What to send

What We Would Need From You

A historic audit runs on the records you already hold.

Field or artifactWhy we need it
Deduction detail export covering the historic periodThe spine of the audit. Every line has to be classifiable by retailer, date, amount, reason and invoice reference before any pattern can be read from it.
Remittance or check detailShows what was actually paid against what was billed.
Retailer deduction reports for your largest accountsThe retailer's own record of what it took and why. Reading it against your export is what separates a deduction you never examined from a deduction your system recorded differently.
Any dispute correspondence that existsIdentifies disputes that were opened and then abandoned.
Stated limits

What a Historic Audit Can and Cannot Produce

A historic audit is an analysis, not a recovery.

  • A closed deduction outside a retailer's dispute window is generally not recoverable. Where that is the case, the value of the audit is the pattern and the evidence, not the money.

  • The audit describes; it does not commit. Nothing in it is a statement of what a retailer would accept, what would be repaid, or how long anything would take.

The deliverable

What Comes Out of It

A historic audit returns the following.

The categories found.

Every classifiable line sorted into what it actually was: never disputed, disputed and abandoned, duplicate, taken more than once, repaid but never credited back, or examined and correctly absorbed.

The root-cause pattern by originator.

Which function inside your business the deductions trace back to, so a fix can be aimed at a cause rather than at the symptom.

What was absorbed without examination.

The portion of the historic book that was never looked at by anyone before it was written off.

What, if any, is still inside a window.

Anything the audit surfaces that has not yet closed belongs in a forward recovery process, and it moves there rather than staying in the audit. That is the Chargeback Recovery Assessment.

Questions

Questions

Can you recover a deduction that is already closed?

Generally not, once the retailer's dispute window has passed. A historic deduction audit is an analysis, not a recovery, and it carries no guarantee and no projection of an outcome.

Is the historic audit a financial audit?

No. A historic deduction audit is not a financial statement audit, a tax audit, or an IT or security audit, and it produces no opinion, attestation or certification of any kind.

Does a person review the work?

Review is selective and exception-based. ROIAI One's own analysts review the exceptions that need judgment, not the customer's team. A historic audit produces analysis rather than submissions, so nothing in it goes to a retailer at all.

Start With the Assessment

If you are unsure which of the two you want, start with a Chargeback Recovery Assessment.

Chat with Roy